Weber's Original Kettle Grill has a tried and true design that grills perfectly, lasts years, and doesn't break the bank.
Pros: Easy to use, clean, outfit, and repair
Cons: Thin steel, the porcelain-enameled coating can crack easily
It's hard not to love the design of the Weber Original Kettle 22-inch charcoal grill. It's been around for decades with hardly any changes, and it probably belongs in the Museum of Modern Art.
The simple, circular shape naturally gathers charcoal evenly in the basin and makes for even heat distribution. Top and bottom vents allow heat control for direct and indirect cooking (as well as ash catchment on the bottom), and the basin is deep enough to add a pan of water to keep meats from drying out when you're cooking low and slow.
It's also a fairly weatherproof and highly mobile grill. The tripod leg design makes tilting and rolling a cinch (as does the handle), and because it's such lightweight stainless steel, you can easily pick it up and place it in the bed of a pickup, or store it away for non-grilling season (if such a thing exists).
We also love how effortless cleaning is; the three-blade ash sweeper and removable ash catcher make disposing of ash easy as can be.
Save for grills made with painted galvanized steel (which, again, aren't built to last), you're not going to find a cheaper grill.
The Weber Original Kettle grill comes in three sizes — 18, 22, and 26 inches in diameter. We like the 22-inch model because it allows you to roast a whole brisket or pork shoulder, but you may want to size up or down depending on your needs. It's also our pick for those on a budget. Buy a cheaper grill as you like, but the difference of about $20 (give or take) isn't worth the loss of several, if not more, years of the good use you'll get out of a Weber.
The Kamado Joe Classic II is a ceramic grill with a teardrop design that burns charcoal efficiently, doubles as a smoker, and retains heat best.
Pros: Excellent insulation and heat retention, fuel-efficient, doubles as smoker, grates set at different heights, sturdy wheel locks
Cons: Heavy, tricky to learn how much charcoal to use (easy to overheat)
As Olunloyo told us, if you have the money, a ceramic kamado grill — a design that originated about 3,000 years ago in Japan — is the best investment you can make in a charcoal grill.
We like the Kamado Joe (KJ) Classic II because it makes few, if any, concessions in quality, but is priced well. Shockingly, you could find yourself paying much more for a grill of similar if not equal construction.
Unlike some of its competitors, the KJ Classic II comes with a robust frame, sturdy (if somewhat small) locking wheels, an adjustable grate, loads of features and multiple grate levels, an ash catchment system, and is virtually weatherproof (still, buy a cover).
Unlike simpler, less-sealed grills, this one will allow you to cook between 225 and 750 degrees Fahrenheit, and maintain a consistent heat, as it's basically a giant ceramic oven.
This also makes it unbelievably efficient, and you'll be amazed to use only about half of what you normally would in a stainless-steel kettle grill.
When it comes to a Kamado-style grill, you won't find much competition for the Kamado Joe Classic II, save for the Big Green Egg, which we also like (more on that one below).
Weber's Smokey Joe is everything we love about the brand's Original Kettle grill, but is travel-sized and even more affordable.
Pros: Lightweight, same design as our top pick
Cons: Not entirely spill-proof, bulky for a portable grill
If you're in the market for a portable charcoal grill, the first thing that you need to know is that they're messy. They're all liable to leak, spill, and trash the trunk of your car, so don't set out without a storage bin or a large, heavy-duty sealed bag to contain grease, ash, and grit.
There are tons of portable grills out there, but the most basic and familiar is the miniature version of our top recommendation, Weber's 14-inch Smokey Joe.
It handles about five (crowded) burgers on the grate, so it's plenty for a normal carload of people, which we find is just right.
If you're looking for something highly portable for camping, there are plenty of fancy options out there, and if you want to spend a few hundred dollars on something extra compact, we really like Snow Peak's. If you're looking for a fire pit and charcoal grill in one, check out Picnic Time's X-Grill, which folds and comes with a pouch to contain the mess — I tend to keep this one in my car, and while it's not the best for cooking, it manages just fine.
Still, if you're looking for something basic and affordable, the Weber Smokey Joe is as convenient and easy to use as our top pick, and it's going to last every bit as long.
Masterbuilt's charcoal grills are ruggedly built to accommodate the largest jobs, but cost a fraction of the price of the upscale grills on the market.
Pros: Solid steel and cast-iron materials, easily loads from front, adjustable rack height, sturdy casters
Cons: Heavy, lengthy setup process, doesn't seal perfectly, 1-year limited warranty, cheap doors
If you're looking for a big charcoal grill, barrel-style smokers are the most common. And if you want to dive straight into the deep end, BBQ University and Project Smoke host and author Steven Raichlen told us to look to Horizon, Yoder, Lang, or Texas Originals, but know that those are big investments.
On the other hand, the average household looking for a charcoal grill capable of smoking would do extremely well with Masterbuilt's 36" Charcoal Grill. We haven't found anything as heavy-duty for the price.
For most people, this is a great and affordable option (the 30-inch model is currently unavailable). Its outer parts are made with stainless steel and cast iron, and the cast-iron grates (while a pain to clean) are hardy.
There are two side-arm tables, and inside, you'll easily fit 20 burgers or a couple of racks of ribs, or up to about eight chickens, and when you're not cooking for a full party, simply start a fire on one side and you have a massive multi-zone cooking station that'll allow you to do anything from sear, to cook low and slow, and even smoke.
Lastly, it's great for wood-smoking, too, thanks to the front-loading door that lets you slide entire split logs into it.
If you want something with a smaller footprint, we also like Weber's Smokey Mountain series' 18-inch smoker.
The New Original PK300 Grill and Smoker is an updated design of the classic PK built to last decades and ready for most backyard barbecues.
Pros: Great heat retention and weather resistance, easy coal access with fold-up grate, 20-year warranty
Cons: No thermometer included
The original PK kettle grill hit the market the same year that the Weber did, and it is among the most efficient and durable small charcoal grills we've tested to date. The new (and we'll definitely say improved) PK300 comes with an impressive 20-year warranty.
The brand can make good on that warranty because, in all likelihood, they won't really have to: As opposed to the thin, powder-coated or porcelain-enameled steel found in more affordable kettle grills (such as the Weber), they use thick, cast aluminum instead. It's not only more heat- and weather-resistant, but much more conductive, meaning you'll have a much easier time getting — and keeping — it hot.
This is the perfect cart design for a casual griller, with just enough cooking area (about 324 square inches) for a small party, a folding shelf for a plate, and a large bottom shelf for a tray.
The new PK 300 also comes with cast-aluminum lugs and legs, so nothing's bound to fall apart or buckle like it would on a cheaper grill.
The series of baffles and the wide surface area make temperature control a breeze and also alow for small smoking endeavors. At $600, it's a bit of an investment for most people, but if you want a simple, efficient grill that will last, this is a fantastic choice.
Big Green Egg: The Big Green Egg and the Kamado Joe are almost identical and stack up neck and neck, with the exception of a few details. The Kamado Joe comes with everything you need, while the Big Green Egg is merely the egg itself, meaning you'll need to buy the stand and the side tables, so it gets a bit more expensive (and also more complex to set up). The Kamado Joe also has sturdier (if smaller) casters (wheels). In terms of cooking, the Kamado Joe is designed with adjustable grates for cooking at different levels, and also has a counterbalanced lid so that it's both easier to lift and it doesn't slam shut on you while your hands are full.
Broil King Keg 5000: A kamado-style grill but made with double-walled stainless steel instead of a ceramic liner, this should function like a Kamado Joe or Big Green Egg, but might not last as long. It probably won't do you wrong, but you may want to save up and invest in a ceramic model down the line.
Char-Griller Acorn Kamado Kooker: A more affordable take on the kamado (made without a ceramic liner), this grill outperforms our top pick in heat retention, but at more than twice the cost. It's a fine grill and we wholeheartedly recommend it, but we think the Weber is the better pick for most people and most budgets.
Char-Griller Double-Play: A two-in-one gas-and-charcoal grill, this is a fine option, but it's not built as well as we'd like, as we noted a few flimsier parts including the wheels, the hardware, and the grate, and the lid doesn't seal terribly well. You'd do better buying your gas and charcoal grills as separate items.
IG Charcoal Grill: We're a big fan of this grill, especially considering the price. If you want to cook over a large, open, adjustable bed of coals, this stainless steel grill can take a beating. We've left it out in the elements (and a stone's throw from the Chesapeake Bay) for two years and counting without so much as a spot of rust. Still, we wouldn't recommend it for most people as it's oversized and doesn't come with a lid, so you have no way of trapping heat. Read our full review of the IG Charcoal grill here.
Kudu: If you want a heavy-gauge steel grill that's going to last ages and make you feel like you're homesteading across the great divide, look no further. We love this grill and highly recommend it. It also makes for an excellent campfire. But when it comes to cooking, it's probably a little too involved for most people. That said, if you want to sit beside a grill and enjoy the heat and atmosphere (this thing also excels with wood fires), it's a wonderful option. Steven Raichlen is a big proponent, too.
Masterbuilt Gravity Series 1050: Among the only grills of its kind, this "GravityFed" digital charcoal grill is basically a wifi pellet grill built for charcoal. It offers a lot of cooking surface area (1050 square inches), and it will allow you to keep a charcoal fire going for a good, long while, though you do have to light it manually from beneath with a piece of paper or food-safe fire-starter.
We used Royal Oak Hardwood Lump Charcoal and managed to get it going well, but had a hard time regulating temperature as well as, say, the Spark Grill below. We will try several more charcoals going forward, but if you are looking for a charcoal smoker that makes the job of keeping the fire going a little easier, this is a good choice. Otherwise, it's a little on the large side, and getting it much hotter than 500 or 600 degrees Fahrenheit has proven difficult, so far.
Napoleon 22" Pro Charcoal Kettle Grill: About twice the price of our top pick, but roughly the same design, we've assembled it and given it a bit of time outside. We like it so far, but we're looking to see if there's anything that makes it worth the price jump.
Nexgrill 29-inch Barrel Charcoal Grill/Smoker: if you're on a tight budget or you just want a charcoal grill (and smoker) in a pinch, this is the best you're going to do, and you will make do. Our hesitation is that this is one of those grills that you could outfit with gaskets to function very well, but the quality of the parts means it's not destined to survive past a couple of years with moderate use.
Spark Grill: If you like the flavor and general effect of charcoal grilling but aren't a fan of building a fire, want to avoid the mess, or want to be able to control your cooking temperature to a T without any fuss, the Spark Grill is the best answer we've found. The charcoal "Briqs," while exclusive and unavailable at your local grocery store, are space-savers compared to a bag of charcoal, but the price (shipping is free) breaks down to roughly the same as what you'd pay for any other charcoal.
Each "Briq" is set to burn within a certain temperature range for a rough given amount of time, so you'll do best to order across the spectrum ("Low & Slow" burns for 4-6 hours at 250-350 degrees Fahrenheit; "High Heat" burns for 30-45 minutes at between 600 and 900 Fahrenheit). Temperature is controlled through a dial, and the grill lights electronically and with ease. We did find the built-in fan to be on the loud side, and we weren't thrilled with the cart design on this, as it seems lightweight for the price you'll pay, but it is sturdy enough.
During our most recent round of testing, we retested our top pick alongside two other contenders to determine which ones were the most convenient to use, offered the best surface area (and use of said surface area), and considered ease of cleaning as well.
In order to select the grills we tested, we walked through The Home Depot and Lowe's to consider options, disregarding grills made with inferior parts or use questionable construction materials, and also taking price ranges into account.
We also spoke with several experts in the field about what to look for in a charcoal grill, from chef Shola Olunloyo of Studio Kitchen to veteran author and TV host Steven Raichlen, Hey Grill Hey founder Susie Bulloch, Thirteen Executive Chef Tobias Dorzon (who's also opening his own restaurant, Huncho House, and is featured on Season 3 of Guy Fieri's Tournament of Champions), and famed New York City butcher Pat LaFrieda.
Here's what we looked for in our top picks:
Ease of use: While a reasonable surface area is a given, we looked for grills with sturdy stainless steel or cast-iron grates, good (open) spacing to allow heat to pass through, and a raised edge to prevent food from rolling or falling off the surface. We also considered the ease of cleaning, and made sure there was a reasonable way of disposing of ashes. Surprisingly, we learned that many charcoal grills don't offer ash catching systems.
Material quality: Grills have to live outside, generally, and while you should purchase and use a cover, a grill is going to have to stand up to some abuse with normal use. We looked for quality stainless steel or ceramic, and seeing that those grills tend to get expensive, we also looked for thinner steel with enamel coating (rather than easily chippable and not-so-rust-proof paint). We also took caster and wheel quality into consideration.
Performance: Of course, performance was a factor we considered as well, but because charcoal grilling depends so largely on the material of the grill, as well as the type, amount, and placement of fuel you use, we chose to focus on the experience of using the grill and the quality of the materials and the design itself. We didn't encounter any grills that cooked poorly, but if we did, they would've been immediately disqualified. We do find that grills with some sort of sealing material, be it a fiberglass or felt gasket maintain temperature and cook much more efficiently.
Warranty: While there's not much a warranty will cover if you misuse (or neglect) your grill, it's good to know when a brand stands behind its products. Because of its prolific presence and its 10-year warranty (on the bowl and lid) to many other brands' one-year warranty, Weber was an easy pick in this department. And while Masterbuilt sadly only offers a year, it's in line with contenders of similar size and price (though we'd still love to see a better warranty offered by the brand).
Sign up for Insider Reviews' weekly newsletter for more buying advice and great deals.
You can purchase logo and accolade licensing to this story here.
Disclosure: Written and researched by the Insider Reviews team. We highlight products and services you might find interesting. If you buy them, we may get a small share of the revenue from the sale from our partners. We may receive products free of charge from manufacturers to test. This does not drive our decision as to whether or not a product is featured or recommended. We operate independently from our advertising team. We welcome your feedback. Email us at reviews@insider.com.