I tried the $6 cookies at Disney Springs that people wait hours in line for, and it was the highlight of my vacation

A classic chocolate chip cookie at Gideon's Bakehouse.
Each cookie at Gideon's Bakehouse is said to weigh nearly half a pound.
Amanda Krause/Insider
  • Gideon's Bakehouse is a gothic-themed bakery with a location at Disney Springs in Florida.
  • The shop's half-pound cookies are the best I've ever had, even after waiting an hour to buy them.
  • I'd also recommend the giant cake slices, which cost $9 and are worth every penny, in my opinion.

Gideon's Bakehouse is a gothic dessert shop that opened in Disney Springs at the start of 2021.

Gideon's Bakehouse at Disney Springs
A sign outside Gideon's Bakehouse promotes cookies, cakes, and "curiosities."
Amanda Krause/Insider

Steve Lewis, the creator of Gideon's Bakery, was inspired to open a shop after buying an 1898 cookbook at an estate sale in the early 2000s.

The book's margins were "filled with faded notes and doodles" from a boy named Gideon who seemingly had dreams of becoming a baker, according to the Gideon's website. Lewis then decided to "fulfill that child's wishes," and first opened a store at Florida's East End Market in 2016.

When I arrived at the shop for the first time in August 2021, Disney Springs was empty and the doors to Gideon's Bakehouse were closed.

Gideon's Bakehouse at Disney Springs.
Even from the outside, you can tell that Gideon's Bakehouse has a gothic aesthetic.
Amanda Krause/Insider

Prior to my trip, I'd read tons of articles and watched numerous videos about how busy Gideon's Bakehouse can get thanks to tourists and its dedicated fans.

I heard that it was best to arrive for the store's opening, so I pulled into the Disney Springs Orange lot around 8:55 a.m., passed through the security checkpoint, and began looking for the bakery.

Disney Springs was essentially a ghost town that early in the morning — I only passed a few employees and some flocks of birds.

As the first person in line, I was able to sit on a cement ledge that lined the store.

Insider reporter Amanda Krause at Disney World's Gideon's Bakehouse.
Gideon's Bakehouse prepares for a long line of visitors before it opens each day.
Amanda Krause/Insider

I was relieved to have a seat, as I planned to wait a full hour before the bakery opened and it was already pretty hot in Florida.

There were also rope barricades in front of the wall, so I knew it was only a matter of time before others showed up.

A crowd started forming about 10 minutes after I arrived, and everyone seemed excited to enter the bakery.

People wait in line to visit Gideon's Bakehouse at Disney Springs.
The line extended past the building as it got closer to 10 a.m. when the store opened.
Amanda Krause/Insider

By 9:45 a.m., I had counted approximately 35 people waiting in line. I assumed many were there early to get their hands on the coffee-cake cookie, which is sold only at the Disney Springs location each morning until they run out.

A few minutes before the store opened, Gideon's employees came outside to hand out menus, answer questions, and share what cake flavors were being sold that day.

A postcard menu from Gideon's Bakehouse at Disney Springs.
You have just enough time to browse the menu before entering the store.
Amanda Krause/Insider

Of course, you can use the Gideon's Bakehouse website and Instagram page to prepare for a visit, but having a physical menu really helped narrow down my order.

The menus also doubled as souvenir postcards printed with one of Gideon's mascots, Signore Pipistrello, which I loved.

We were led into the store approximately six minutes early. Right away, I was in awe of the tiny bakery.

Artwork inside Gideon's Bakery at Disney Springs.
These are just some of the framed illustrations that line the wall of Gideon's Bakehouse.
Amanda Krause/Insider

My eyes were immediately drawn to the art gallery that lined the left wall of the store.

I loved how unique each character drawing was, and the standout atmosphere made it clear that Gideon's Bakehouse is unlike any other bakery you might visit.

I took a brief pause to look around and let my eyes adjust to the shop's dark atmosphere. Then I quickly made my way over to the register.

Inside Gideon's Bakehouse at Disney Springs in Orlando, Florida.
In addition to cakes and cookies, you can also buy Gideon's Bakehouse merchandise.
Amanda Krause/Insider

The employees were extremely nice, in my experience, and told the customers to enjoy themselves and look around. I noticed a small merchandise section to the left where you could buy candles, shirts, and more, and registers against the wall in the store's center.

There, I found Gideon's famous cookies arranged inside glass cases along the register.

Cookies at Gideon's Bakehouse in Disney Springs.
It's almost impossible to choose only a few desserts to buy once you're in the store.
Amanda Krause/Insider

According to the Gideon's Bakehouse website, its cookies are handmade each day in small batches. They retail for $6 each, which is a bargain in my opinion when you consider that each weighs nearly half a pound.

I had already planned my order while waiting in line, but the display desserts made me reconsider. I wished I could have ordered one of everything.

There were also giant cakes to show you what slices you could buy.

Cakes at Gideon's Bakehouse in Disney Springs.
The three-layered cake slices are giant and covered in frosting.
Amanda Krause/Insider

Gideon's typically sells red-velvet cake and other rotating flavors, including some secret-menu options. Each slice costs $9, and cakes take approximately 24 hours to prepare.

I wanted to keep my focus on the shop's cookies, so I only planned to buy one slice of cake, but they all made my mouth water. 

By that point, I couldn't wait another minute to place my order.

Cashiers at Gideon's Bakehouse in Disney Springs.
Gideon's Bakehouse employees are helpful and quick to place your order.
Amanda Krause/Insider

I ordered an original chocolate-chip cookie, a slice of red-velvet cake, a pistachio-toffee cookie, and a coffee-cake cookie for the purpose of this review. 

Luckily my dad was with me and wanted some desserts of his own, so I also got to try a few other flavors, like the peanut-butter crunch, triple-chocolate, and rocky-road cookies.

The cookies were packed into fancy boxes and stacked with paper in between to keep them from melting together.

Cookies from Gideon's Bakehouse in Orlando, Florida.
Be prepared to walk and eat after leaving Gideon's Bakehouse.
Amanda Krause/Insider

I was eager to try the desserts fresh, but unfortunately, there are no tables and chairs outside of Gideon's.

That being said, finding a place to stop wasn't much of a problem. I walked a few steps around the corner of the store and found another cement ledge where I could place my food and enjoy a few bites.

I knew the fan-favorite cookies would be large, but I was still surprised at how truly massive they are.

Amanda Krause at Gideon's Bakehouse in Florida.
In my opinion, Gideon's giant cookies are a steal for only $6 each.
Amanda Krause/Insider

Each cookie was close to being the size of my face, and they weighed a hefty amount too. That being said, I found that it was almost easier — and definitely less messy — to break pieces off the cookies rather than to bite them directly.

My favorite cookies by far were the pistachio-toffee and coffee-cake versions.

A coffee cake and pistachio cookie from Gideon's Bakehouse in Orlando, Florida.
I'd recommend these cookies to anyone visiting Gideon's Bakehouse at Disney Springs.
Amanda Krause/Insider

The pistachio cookie made for the perfect combination of salty and sweet flavors, while the coffee-cake option tasted better than any crumb cake I've ever had.

In my opinion, the latter cookie alone is worth an early-morning trip to the bakery. It'd be perfect to pair with coffee or your breakfast.

I also loved the classic chocolate-chip and triple-chocolate cookies.

A chocolate chip and triple chocolate cookie from Gideon's Bakehouse.
Chocolate lovers will want to try both of these Gideon's cookies.
Amanda Krause/Insider

While it's difficult to mess up a chocolate-chip cookie, Gideon's has perfected the recipe, in my opinion. They're coated in dozens of chocolate chips and the perfect amount of salt, while the cookie itself almost tastes like soft dough out of the fridge.

I also loved the triple-chocolate option. It was also cake-like in texture, with distinct flavors of different chocolate mixed in. The sea salt on top added the perfect balance of extra flavor and prevented the cookie from being too sweet.

The peanut butter and rocky-road cookies weren't my favorites, but I can't deny that they're still delicious.

Peanut butter and rocky road cookies from Gideon's Bakehouse.
The rocky-road cookie was a limited-edition option for visitors in August.
Amanda Krause/Insider

I only like to eat peanut butter in small doses, so I knew I wouldn't love Gideon's cookie that's covered in peanut-butter chips. Still, the few bites I had were pretty delicious, and my dad — who's a huge peanut butter fan — devoured the entire cookie right away. 

Then there was the rocky-road cookie, which was a limited-edition release for August. We both agreed that it was good, but a bit forgettable when compared to the others we tried.

There are a few things I'd wished I'd known before my first trip.

People wait outside Gideon's Bakehouse at Disney Springs.
Even when I was leaving Gideon's Bakehouse, there was a line out the door.
Amanda Krause/Insider

As I ate my way through the selection of gourmet cookies, I found myself feeling extremely thirsty. And because we were eating in the Florida sun, the cookies began to melt and chocolate was getting everywhere. In the future, I'd be sure to bring water and wet hand wipes with me.

We also got some tips from an employee, who kindly approached us to ask how we were as we ate outside. She said that Mondays through Thursdays are the best times to visit, especially in the mid-afternoon and back-to-school season when crowds are low. 

If you visit on a weekend, however, she noted that you should be prepared to wait in a virtual line for up to four hours.

I saved the giant cake slice for when I got back to my hotel room.

Red velvet cake from Gideon's Bakehouse.
The red-velvet cake is covered in buttercream icing and walnuts on the side.
Amanda Krause/Insider

After digesting all the cookies I ate, I decided it was time to try Gideon's red-velvet cake. Unfortunately, it tasted a bit dry, in my opinion, and the flavor wasn't sweet enough for my liking.

My dad, however, said he would "order it again in a heartbeat," and he's not usually a fan of red velvet. So I'd say it's still worth a try.

In the months since, I've visited Gideon's Bakehouse on numerous occasions, and I've tried other flavors that blow this one out of the water. I particularly love the limited-edition Christmas cakes, and the vibrant Rainbow Crunch slices.

I've found that Gideon's Bakehouse can be equally busy at night.

People wait to buy dessert from Gideon's Bakehouse in July 2022.
People wait to buy dessert from Gideon's Bakehouse in July 2022.
Amanda Krause/Insider

During more recent trips to Disney Springs, I've seen large crowds outside the bakery as late as 8 p.m. 

Though the lines look intimidating, I've found that they're usually not that bad. In July 2022, I waited in a line that extended to the Morimoto Asia restaurant next door, and I was in the bakery 30 minutes later. The time flew by.

Not only are Gideon's Bakehouse cookies the best at Disney World, in my opinion, but I'd argue that they're the best I've ever had.

Insider reporter Amanda Krause at Gideon's Bakehouse in Disney Springs.
It's safe to say that I'm a huge fan of Gideon's Bakehouse.
Amanda Krause/Insider

Before visiting Disney World in 2021, I'd spent months following Gideon's Bakehouse on Instagram and dreaming of trying its famous cookies. I was worried that they wouldn't live up to my expectations, but they far exceeded them in the end.

The half-pound desserts were delicious and fairly priced, in my opinion, and the process to buy them was unique and fun. I loved them so much that I've visited Disney Springs on numerous occasions since then, mostly to stop at the bakery.

So it's safe to say that I'll continuously recommend the bakery to fellow travelers, and daydream about the time when I can visit again.

Deal icon An icon in the shape of a lightning bolt.

Keep reading

Close icon Two crossed lines that form an 'X'. It indicates a way to close an interaction, or dismiss a notification.